Beiträge von neono

  • [RAID] Festplatten lösen sich aus Raid 5 Verbund

    Zitat von "der chris"

    Hi,


    habe die WDs mit 1,5 TB bisher etwas über ne Woche in Betrieb (täglich zeitgesteuertes hoch und runterfahren) und bisher keine derartigen Probleme...
    Nach welcher Zeit trat das Problem erstmals bei Dir auf?
    Grüße
    Chris


    Hi Chris,


    kommt drauf an. Manchmal mehrmals am Tag und gestern ist es fast 6 Tage am Stück gut gegangen. Es kommt aber auch darauf an, welche Hardware Du einsetzt. Ist es genau dieselbe wie ich sie habe? Hast Du auch RAID 5? Gestern trat das Problem auf nachdem ich das NAS manuell hochgefahren hatte.


    Übrigens der QNAP Support ist auch schon an der Sache dran und werden das Problem analysieren.

  • [RAID] Festplatten lösen sich aus Raid 5 Verbund

    Hallo zusammen,


    kleines Update zu meinem Problem kurz zusammengefaßt:
    1. Neues TS439Pro geordert.
    2. Gleiches Problem mit den Western Digital 1,5TB (WDC WD15EADS-00R6B0 01.0) Platten aufgetreten. Wahlweise verabschieden sich die Platten im Raid nach einem Neustart.
    3. BAD Block Sector Test für alle Platten durchgeführt. Diese sind in Ordnung.
    4. Es liegt wohl an den Platten im Zusammenspiel mit den NAS.


    Also Finger weg von den Western Digital 1,5 TB Platten!! :!:

  • [RAID] Festplatten lösen sich aus Raid 5 Verbund

    Hallo zusammen,


    ich habe mir seid letzter Woche eine TS-439 Pro zugelegt und diese mit 4x 1,5TB (WDC WD15EADS-00R6B0 01.0) Festplatten bestückt. Leider ist das NAS immer wieder in den "Degraded Mode" gegangen weil immer wieder sich eine Festplatte aus dem Raid 5 Verbund gelöst hat. Rebuild hat immer funktioniert. Diese Ausfälle passieren zu unterschiedlichen Zeiten bei verschiedenen Platten. Ich habe mittlerweile die Festplatten schon durchgeprüft (Scanning bad blocks).
    Ergebnis war, dass die Festplatten anscheinend in Ordnung sind. Auch ein Firmware Upgrade habe ich auf die neueste Version von 2.1.6 to 3.1.0. durchgeführt. Leider bleibt das Problem bestehen. Auch eine Neuformatierung auf EXT4 hat keinen nennenswerten Effekt erzielt.
    Nun meine Frage, hatte jemand schon die gleichen Probleme? Handelt es sich hier um einen Hardwaredefekt des NAS?


    Anbei ein Auszug aus dem Systemprotokoll:


    100,"2","2009-07-01","20:36:28","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Drive 2 failed."
    99,"1","2009-07-01","20:36:27","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] RAID device is in degraded mode."
    98,"0","2009-07-01","20:36:27","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Drive 2 has been removed."
    97,"0","2009-07-01","17:37:26","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[Drive 4] Start Scanning bad blocks."
    96,"0","2009-07-01","13:30:28","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Rebuilding done."
    95,"0","2009-07-01","07:05:56","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Start rebuilding."
    94,"0","2009-07-01","07:04:15","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Drive 4 has been added into Volume 1."
    93,"0","2009-07-01","07:03:56","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    92,"0","2009-07-01","07:00:59","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Wed Jul 1 07:00:59 CEST 2009."
    91,"0","2009-07-01","06:54:45","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    90,"0","2009-07-01","00:16:23","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Wed Jul 1 00:16:23 CEST 2009."
    89,"0","2009-06-30","23:57:32","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[USBDisk1] Device removed successfully.
    "
    88"",""0"",""2009-06-30"",""19:59:31"",""System"",""192.168.178.26"",""---"",""Remote Replication: Disable Remote Replication function"""
    87,"0","2009-06-30","18:58:08","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[USBDisk1] Device detected. The file system is ntfs."
    86,"0","2009-06-30","17:30:58","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","Lan 1 link is Up."
    85,"0","2009-06-30","17:30:58","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","Lan 2 link is UP."
    84,"0","2009-06-30","17:30:54","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","Lan 2 link is Down."
    83,"0","2009-06-30","17:30:53","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","Lan 1 link is Down."
    82,"0","2009-06-30","17:20:43","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[UPnP] has been enabled"
    81,"0","2009-06-30","17:18:33","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Formatting completed."
    80,"0","2009-06-30","17:07:34","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Start formatting."
    79,"0","2009-06-30","17:03:54","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    78,"0","2009-06-30","17:01:07","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Tue Jun 30 17:01:07 CEST 2009."
    77,"0","2009-06-30","16:55:39","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    76,"0","2009-06-30","16:52:55","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Tue Jun 30 16:52:55 CEST 2009."
    75,"0","2009-06-30","16:52:17","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was updated successfully from 2.1.6 to 3.1.0."
    74,"0","2009-06-30","12:59:42","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Rebuilding done."
    73,"0","2009-06-30","06:38:42","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Start rebuilding."
    72,"0","2009-06-30","06:37:37","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Drive 4 has been added into Volume 1."
    71,"0","2009-06-30","06:37:19","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    70,"0","2009-06-30","06:32:31","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Tue Jun 30 06:32:31 CEST 2009."
    69,"0","2009-06-30","06:26:56","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Recovering journal."
    68,"0","2009-06-30","06:26:32","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    67,"1","2009-06-30","06:26:32","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","The system was not shut down properly last time."
    66,"2","2009-06-30","06:22:05","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Error occurred while accessing Drive 2."
    65,"0","2009-06-29","19:40:53","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[USBDisk1] Device detected. The file system is ntfs."
    64,"0","2009-06-29","17:05:38","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    63,"0","2009-06-29","07:22:21","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Mon Jun 29 07:22:21 CEST 2009."
    62,"0","2009-06-29","06:06:48","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Rebuilding done."
    61,"0","2009-06-28","23:47:37","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Start rebuilding."
    60,"0","2009-06-28","23:46:27","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Drive 4 has been added into Volume 1."
    59,"0","2009-06-28","23:46:08","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    58,"0","2009-06-28","23:43:17","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Sun Jun 28 23:43:17 CEST 2009."
    57,"0","2009-06-28","23:40:17","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","HDD SMART: HDD 1 Quick Test result: Completed without error. The current temperature is 36 ºC."
    56,"0","2009-06-28","23:38:15","admin","192.168.178.26","localhost","HDD SMART: HDD 1 Quick Test started."
    55,"0","2009-06-28","23:38:11","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","HDD SMART: HDD 2 Quick Test result: Completed without error. The current temperature is 37 ºC."
    54,"0","2009-06-28","23:36:10","admin","192.168.178.26","localhost","HDD SMART: HDD 2 Quick Test started."
    53,"0","2009-06-28","23:36:06","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","HDD SMART: HDD 3 Quick Test result: Completed without error. The current temperature is 38 ºC."
    52,"0","2009-06-28","23:34:05","admin","192.168.178.26","localhost","HDD SMART: HDD 3 Quick Test started."
    51,"0","2009-06-28","23:25:34","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","HDD SMART: HDD 4 Quick Test result: Completed without error. The current temperature is 38 ºC."
    50,"0","2009-06-28","23:23:33","admin","192.168.178.26","localhost","HDD SMART: HDD 4 Quick Test started."
    49,"0","2009-06-28","23:04:18","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Examination completed."
    48,"0","2009-06-28","21:44:33","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Start examination."
    47,"1","2009-06-28","21:42:26","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] The file system is not cleaned. It is suggested that you to run "check disk"."
    46,"0","2009-06-28","21:42:23","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","[RAID5 Disk Volume: Drive 1 2 3 4] Recovering journal."
    45,"0","2009-06-28","21:41:59","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    44,"0","2009-06-28","15:12:47","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Sun Jun 28 15:12:47 CEST 2009."
    43,"0","2009-06-28","14:09:22","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."
    42,"0","2009-06-27","18:15:04","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System was shut down on Sat Jun 27 18:15:04 CEST 2009."
    41,"0","2009-06-27","16:16:42","System","127.0.0.1","localhost","System started."


    Ich bin wirklich verzweifelt. Es wäre schön, wenn mir jemand in diesem Fall weiterhelfen könnte. Vielen Dank!